A recent comment on my blog indicates people are not really reading my posts and think I am in favor of legalizing drugs.
I read a few articles on the ‘Anti-War on Drug’ meme and a common theme is that there is a lack of proportion between the damage a drug does and the legal response to it. For example, marijuana has some limited use in treating pain. It doesn’t impare driving. Regardless to that, the legal response should be great enough to get people to stop using it after society has decided to get people to stop using it. If anything, the legal response against drugs is too mild, in most cases. Look at Afganistan. The only way they got the drug problem under control over there was to cut off peoples hands. Look what the US backed government has accomplished. Opium growing and use is rampant again. The idea that a criminal pays triple damages is well established, for example in financial crimes, criminals pay triple damages. In drug law, criminals should pay 1000 times their damage to society, it is the only thing that will get their attention.
The war on drugs is a lot of issues. Each drug really should have it’s own policy, since they cause different problems and fall in different places on the spectrum of victimless to victim crimes.
Tobacco. Nonsmokers are the victims–worst of all are the quality of life issues- I can’t stand people smoking around me, second is the damage done to the housing stock, and finally the extra money I have to spend cleaning cloths that stink like cigarettes every time I go to a night club. Some smoker out there is currently ruining the carpet in my future apartment. Smoking is still widespread and generally legal. People smoke less the hard to you make it to buy and them more expensive you make it. Tobacco is still mostly in the formal economy. While it is pleasant to know that smokers are slowing killing themselves, it is not fast enough. The government should require every 1000′th cigarette to have cyanide in it.
Alcohol. Alcohol is a problem when someone drinks enough that they can’t drive.
Marijuana. Marijuana has the same problems as tobacco. If Marijuana was legalized, then not only would my cloths stink like tobacco everytime I went to a night club, they’d also stink like Marijuana. Impaling Marijuana users on a pike is not good enough.
Cocaine and other euphorics. Cocaine destroys your ability to feel happy without using euphorics, permanently. It is a defective product and should be kept off the market. If libertarians were taking defective aspirin that destroyed their ability to feel happiness, permanently, then they might be unhappy with the result. They might even regret that they had ruined their brain’s ability to enjoy anything. Euphoric abusers tend to be unreliable folk who keep quiting their jobs and relationships to seek out some happiness because they can’t get it from working or having friends. Why libertarians want an ever increasing number of these zombies on the street, I don’t know.
Hallucinogens. We’ve got limited resources, so lesser damaging drugs like LSD probably should get some other sort of policy, but I’m not sure what.
So, just because I got to get back to work, here are some policies, first for the stick and then the carrots:
1) Penalties with teeth. Like maybe letting drug dealers be ripped to pieces by dogs on national TV.
2) Declare war on Mexico and Columbia and maybe Canada. F*ck Iraq, lets send the Marines to Mexico, Belize and Columbia. While the Canadians generally have been allies in the past, transshipping drugs isn’t exactly what allies are supposed to do.
3) Increase taxes on tobacco.
4) Set a maximum amount of booze that any one person can buy.
5) Disabuse ourselves of a rosy world where people could freely choose to use marijuana, alcohol, tobacco, cocaine, heroine and meth without out any costs to those around them.
Carrots.
And we need to do more to address the social needs of drug abusers in the first place–policies to address unemployment, persistent poverty, low levels of education, etc.